Matt Cole is an experienced analyst, author, and academic with the desire to share knowledge.

The Didactic Method: What It Is and What the Research Says

The didactic method is teacher-led instruction. The teacher decides what students need to learn, explains it, shows how it is done, has students practice, and checks the result. It is also called direct or explicit instruction. The word “didactic” comes from a Greek word meaning “apt at teaching.”

People often use “didactic” as an insult for a boring lecture. The research is more specific than that. Teacher-led instruction works well for some goals and badly for others, and the difference is in how it is done.

What it looks like in a classroom

A didactic lesson usually follows this order:

  1. State the goal. Students know what they will be able to do by the end.
  2. Explain in small pieces. New material comes in steps small enough to hold in mind at once.
  3. Model. The teacher works an example aloud, including the thinking.
  4. Guided practice. Students try it with the teacher watching and correcting.
  5. Independent practice. Students work alone once they are mostly accurate.
  6. Review. Earlier material comes back on a schedule.

Compare that with a lesson where students are given a problem and asked to discover the method. That is the other end of the range, usually called inquiry or discovery learning.

What the research says

It works for beginners learning new, well-defined material. In 2006, Paul Kirschner, John Sweller and Richard Clark published “Why Minimal Guidance During Instruction Does Not Work” in Educational Psychologist. They argued that minimally guided approaches (discovery, problem-based and inquiry learning) are less effective and less efficient than strongly guided instruction, because human working memory is limited. They also noted the advantage of guidance recedes once learners have enough prior knowledge. Other researchers published replies disputing the paper, so treat it as one side of a real debate.

The best-known checklist comes from observing effective teachers. Barak Rosenshine summarized decades of classroom research in “Principles of Instruction” (American Educator, 2012). Its ten principles are:

  1. Begin each lesson with a short review of earlier learning.
  2. Present new material in small steps, with student practice after each step.
  3. Ask many questions and check the responses of all students.
  4. Provide models.
  5. Guide student practice.
  6. Check for student understanding.
  7. Obtain a high success rate.
  8. Provide scaffolds for difficult tasks.
  9. Require and monitor independent practice.
  10. Engage students in weekly and monthly review.

Notice that most of these are not lecturing. The effective version of didactic teaching is a loop of explaining, asking, and correcting.

Learning styles are not a reason to change the method. Many teaching guides, including the earlier version of this page, say to adapt direct instruction to each student’s learning style. A 2008 review by Harold Pashler and colleagues in Psychological Science in the Public Interest found no adequate evidence base for matching instruction to students’ diagnosed learning styles. What does help is matching the format to the content: a diagram for a diagram, a worked example for a procedure, a map for geography.

When it fits and when it does not

GoalTeacher-led instruction fits?
Facts, vocabulary, definitions, notationYes
A procedure with a correct order (long division, a lab technique, a code convention)Yes
Prerequisite knowledge for a harder taskYes
Open-ended problems with no single methodUse it for the basics, then shift to guided problem solving
Students who already know the area wellLess so. Methods that help novices can become less effective, or even counterproductive, for more expert learners (Kalyuga and colleagues, 2003)
Motivation, discussion, building argumentsNeeds student talk, not only teacher talk

Common mistakes

  • Explaining for too long without checking. If no student has answered a question in ten minutes, the teacher does not know what the class understood.
  • Asking only volunteers. Rosenshine’s principle is to check all students, for example with whiteboards, cold calling, or a quick written answer.
  • Skipping the review. Material taught once and never revisited fades. Brief, spaced review is part of the method.
  • Moving to independent practice too early. Rosenshine’s research points to a high success rate before students work alone.
  • Treating it as the only method. It is a tool for building knowledge. It is not designed to build every skill.

A short planning checklist

Before a lesson, answer these:

  • What exactly should a student be able to do at the end?
  • What is the smallest first step, and what example will I model?
  • What three questions will show me whether they got it?
  • Which earlier material do I review at the start?
  • What will students practice alone, and when will it be reviewed again?

If you teach computer science or another standards-based subject, see our Oklahoma computer science standards by grade guide for how the state sequences what students learn. For a contrasting approach based on discussion, see The Paideia Method.

What do you use direct instruction for, and where has it failed you? Reply with your grade and subject, and I will cover it in a future post. Join the newsletter to get new teaching guides as they are published.

Sources

Similar Posts

One Comment

Comments are closed.